December Reading Diary

I have an intense fondness for fairytale-esque books with deep winter settings. For some reason I love reading about snowy landscapes and feeling the chill run through me. Examples include Northern Lights, The Bear and The Nightingale and Spinning Silver. In December I found out that there is a sub genre for these books called ‘polar fantasy’. I was happy about this because it makes them easier to find. The last three books in this list come under this category.

The First Girl Child by Amy Harmon

“Be careful what you fear, Ivo replied, grave. We draw the attention of the fates when our fear grows too loud. The fates are cruel, and they will reward you with what you fear most.”

From reading fantasy novels over the last few years I’ve discovered that I prefer those that have some grounding in folklore or mythology. The First Girl Child is set on an island in the North Sea with a clan culture following a mix of Norse gods and Christianity

The story begins with Keeper (priest) Dagmar taking in his sister’s son, Bayr, after she dies in childbirth. As she’s dying she curses the islanders to never again produce a girl child and ensures that Bayr will be their only salvation. The relationship between Dagmar and Bayr is an endearing, loving one and Bayr grows up with inhuman strength. He is tasked with protecting the first – and only – girl child who is claimed to be born to the King. However, Alba’s true parentage is hidden and as a decade passes without any more female children, the situation on the island becomes more and more fraught.

The romance in the last quarter was verging on purple prose but I understand Harmon is more known for her romance. Aside from that, I liked the dynamic between the King, the clans and the Keepers and the relationships between the various characters. 4/5

Blackberry & Wild Rose by Sonia Velton

“But there are no secrets in London. Even the houses lean across the narrow alleys towards each other and offer up their scandals in the blink of an open curtain.”

Perhaps my favourite spot in London is Dennis Severs’ House in Spitalfields. The artist spent years recreating the home of a Huguenot silk weaving family from the 1700s through the 1800s. The fact you have to walk through it in silence allows you to soak up its distinctive atmosphere. My love for the house drew me to this book which is set in a similar household in Spitalfields Square during the 1700s.

Esther is married to a silk weaver and offers to take in a woman from a local brothel as a maid. For the first half of the novel they have an uneasy relationship simmering with resentment. However in the second half, a revolt by the journeymen weavers throws them together during a court case. Back then you could hang for maliciously damaging silk, it was that precious. I stayed up till midnight to find out the outcome of the trial and I haven’t done that in a long while 4.25/5

The Raven and the Reindeer by T. Kingfisher

“Do you have a name?” asked Gerta. “I do,” said the raven. Gerta waited. The raven fluffed its beard. “I am the Sound of Mouse Bones Crunching Under the Hooves of God.”

This is a very modern retelling of Hans Christian Anderson’s The Snow Queen. Greta sees her childhood love stolen away by the Snow Queen and sets out for the Far North to rescue him. This irked me in as much as he never did anything to deserve her devotion but there is a nice twist to this. Along the way, she is kidnapped by a witch – and then a bandit – and helped by a raven and reindeer. It was a nice pre-Christmas read. 3.75/5

The Night Before Christmas by Nikolai Gogol

“What the . . . Look, Panas, the moon’s gone.” “So it is,” Kum agreed phlegmatically. “Right, and you just accept it, like that’s the way it should be?” “Well, what else can I do about it?” “What devil has done this to the moon, I want to know? May he never have a shot of vodka in the morning,”

Apparently this fairytale written in 1831 is still sometimes told to Ukrainian and Russian children on Christmas Eve. I wonder what they make of it. It tells the story of the night before Christmas when the devil steals the moon to wreak havoc on a village’s residents. It only gets more bizarre from there. A local witch hides her lovers in sacks to prevent them discovering each other while a blacksmith is set a seemingly impossible task to win the heart of the incredibly vain and unpleasant village beauty. By the end I was more baffled than anything else. I guess I’m used to fairytales with a moral or neat storyline. I do think I was reading a pretty poor translation though. If you know the story, please let me know your thoughts in the comments. 2.75/5

The Snow Child by Eowyn Ivey

“In my old age, I see that life itself is often more fantastic and terrible than the stories we believed as children, and that perhaps there is no harm in finding magic among the trees.”

This is a reworking of a Russian fairytale about a childless old couple who build a girl from snow which then comes to life.

Set in the 1920s, ageing Mabel and Jack move to the wilds of Alaska to escape the prying eyes of others after a stillbirth. They buy a homestead out by the mountains but their isolation only magnifies their loss as they struggle to survive through the winter. Mabel is suicidal at the start of the book.

On the first day of snowfall they make a snowman that they shape into a child. The next morning they see footprints leading away from the snow child and spot a little girl in the forest wearing its scarf and mittens. This child fills the hole and gives them a new reason to keep going.

The setting and nature writing were beautiful and I truly loved the stoic yet warm-hearted Jack and Mabel. However as much as I love fairytales and fantasy I seem to struggle when books are 95% gritty realism and then 5% magic mixed in, like here.

As a result the magical element felt inexplicable and a little jarring. We find out the child has human parentage but she appears to be able to control the snow. We never really get an explanation, which left me rather unsatisfied. I think this is peculiar to me though, going by other reviews. I like clear answers! 4/5

How was your reading in December? Does polar fantasy appeal to you at all?


Filed under Book Review

15 responses to “December Reading Diary

  1. bonkersvanessa

    I like the covers of several of those books *so much* that I would almost want to own them for that reason alone, even though I probably am not into polar fantasy. Great name for the genre!

    I *am* drawn to the Sonia Velton book, despite its having the least appealing cover!, as I have long wanted to visit Dennis Severs’ house, and was thwarted during 2020. I never used to like books in historical settings, but am reading one set in the 17th century at the moment and pushing past my prejudice nicely.

    Ref attractive covers…look where that got me with Everything Under, hehe, another book that failed to integrate the fantasy and the real elements imho. I still might crack for the raven one. 😉


    • bonkersvanessa

      Ah dear, the raven story is e-book only…but loving the name of the publisher…Red Wombat Tea Company!


    • Did you know that they call that a ‘cover buy’? Not as fun as ‘polar fantasy’ but book people have plenty of jargon.

      I hope you get to visit the house before too long. Maybe you’ll be able to come down next December and see it decorated for Christmas.

      Let me know if you’d recommend the historical fiction when you’re finished. I like the genre because in many ways it’s just as transportive as fantasy.


  2. Jillie

    As you love the Dennis Severs house, I am sure you would enjoy the Angela Flanders scented candle, room spray and burning oil that were created for perfuming the property, called “Mr Severs”! A lovely Christmassy smell of orange and spices. I use the oil in my diffuser in the build-up to the festive season and pretend I am at the house!


  3. Hamamelis

    I am on a Ruth Galloway spree. Anything easy, engaging and not too gory will do at the moment. But I am very happy with your post and recommendations, and to discover that one of my favourite genres has a name! I loved the Nightengale, Northern Lights and Spinning Silver. And as our lockdown has been extended with another 3 weeks, pffffff, and this will strain our business (and us) even further, escapism is a necessity…

    p.s. My husband read Where the crawdads sing and he loved it


    • Isn’t it fun to find out about polar fantasy?!
      I can well imagine escapism is vital at this time and spending a while in the frozen North is great.

      So happy to hear your husband enjoyed Where The Crawdads Sing!


  4. Hey Tara,
    I love the way you are able to punch through so many diverse books each month.
    I’m still suffering readers block and also a heft dose of reader envy at your continued monthly numbers.
    The Polar Fantasy genre sounds excellent. I’ll come back and check these when I wade through my current tome.
    Portia xx


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.